Background
Extensive fragmentation of plant populations due to land clearance has
occurred in Australia during the last 100 years. An important concern
in conservation biology is the predicted reduction in viability and
persistence of small, isolated populations. Population genetic theory
suggests that inbreeding will increase in small populations, leading
to increased expression of deleterious alleles (inbreeding depression).
However, there have been few attempts to quantify these parameters,
or to integrate this theory with a knowledge of plant breeding systems
and interactions with pollinators.
Funding from Australian Flora Foundation during 1993 has allowed examination
of the effects of small population size on the rare plant species, Grevillea
barklyana, using an integrated ecological and genetic approach
Specifically, the aim of this study was to examine pollinators, seed
set, mating patterns, and inbreeding depression in G. barklyana
populations that differ in size (numbers of plants).
Study sites
Observations and experimental work were conducted in five populations
of Grevillea barklyana spp. maccleayana near Jervis
Bay on the NSW south coast. Populations varied in size from approximately
50 to 500 plants.
Summary of Results
(1) Self-fertility and inbreeding depression
Hand-pollination experiments in several populations indicated that G.
barklyana plants are fully self-fertile. Plants are also able to
automatically self-pollinate, thereby ensuring reproduction in the absence
of pollinators. Selfed and outcrossed seeds are viable and produce vigorous
seedlings. Self-fertility and the apparent high fitness of selfed progeny
relative to outcrossed progeny suggest that inbreeding depression is
not occurring in G. barklyana populations, although further
examination especially under field conditions is necessary. Lack of
inbreeding depression may be the result of recessive lethal alleles
being purged from populations by repeated setting over a long time period.
(2) Mating system analyses
Electrophoretic examination of mating patterns in several populations
indicated that the majority of seeds produced were the products of self-fertilization.
In one population, where the genotypes of individual plants were determined
by electrophoresis, there was virtually no exchange of genes between
immediately adjacent plants. The implications of high levels of selfing
include increased homozygosity, decreased genetic diversity and, in
the long term, increased nsk cf extinction as a result of reduced ability'
to adapt to changing environmental conditions, interestingly, some variation
in mating patterns was evident, with relatively high levels of outcro-ssing
being detected in one large population. In general, mating system analyses
were hampered by low levels of electrophoretic variability. More powerful
molecular techniques ore new required to further investigate the mating
system and genetic variation within and between populations.
Although high selfing-rates are not uncommon in self-fertile plants,
the high selfing rates in G. barklyana were inconsistent with
the abundance and foraging behaviour of bird-pollinators in the study
populations. Bird pollinators were abundant in all populations examined
and birds moved frequently between plants during their foraging bouts,
potentially transferring cross pollen. The high levels of selfing, despite
the abundance of cross-pollinating floral visitors, may be explained
by the presence of introduced honeybees (Apis mellifera) which
visit newly-opened flowers to collect pollen. Foraging behaviours of
pollen-collecting honeybees at newly opened flowers results in self-pollination.
Self pollen deposited by bees would pre-empt ovules, thereby rendering
later visits by cross-pollinating birds ineffective. Pollen-collecting
honeybees may also reduce crcss-pollination by birds because less pollen
is available for transfer between plants.
Self-pollination by honeybees has importance consequences for G.
barklyana because low outcrossing rates will occur regardless of
the abundance of birds. In conservation biology there is concern about
the effects of introduced honeybees on native plants, although at present
there is a dearth of experimental data. Most work to date has focused
on the fact that honeybees often remove floral rewards but do not pollinate
flowers. The present results suggest that introduced honeybees can also
have more subtle effects, that nevertheless, have far-ranging implications
for plant populations.
(3) Selective abortion
Although plants rely on external agents for pollen transfer, they can
nevertheless exhibit considerable control over paternity and consequently
the genetic quality of their progeny. Mechanisms promoting non-random
mating is an active area of research and has profound implications for
both the basic and applied plant sciences. In G. barklyana,
many more fruits are initiated than mature. I investigated whether plants
were able to selectively abort selfed fruits in favour of outcrossed
fruits. Experiments in two populations in which some flowers on inflorescences
were cross-pollinated and others were self-pollinated indicated that
G. barklyana lacks the ability to selectively abort selfed
fruits. This result is particularly interesting because selective abortion
of selfed fruits has been demonstrated in related species (e.g. Vaughton
and Carthew 1993, Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 50: 35-46). The inability of plants
to discriminate between self and crossed progeny would contribute to
the observed low outcrossing rates in G. barklyana.
(4) Fruit and seed production
Seed production in five populations was found to be consistently low
(about 0.1%). Seed set was was primarily limited by the availability
of resources for fruit production and seed filling; most fertilized
ovules do not initiate fruits and many juvenile fruits abort during
development. Reproductive output was not limited by either the quantity
or quality of pollen received. Hand cross-pollinations using pollen
from the same and different populations failed to increase seed set
over natural levels.
Caging experiments indicated that pre-dispersal predation of immature
fruits by parrots contributed to the low number of mature seeds produced
per plant. Moreover, not all seeds produced by plants are available
for recruitment. About 90% of mature seeds are eaten shortly after release
from the parent plant by nocturnal mammal predators, probably Ratttus
fuscipes. This is important because Grevillea barklyana
is killed by fire and thus relies on its soil-stored seed bank for recovery.
Estimation of seed bank size in five populations suggested that although
most stored seeds were viable, small seed bank size may potentially
limit recruitment after fire. This finding has implications for management,
particularly the frequency of controlled burns.